Effects of surface modification processes on the adhesion of hydroxyapatite layers coated onto titanium substrates


  • Oratai Jongprateep Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University
  • Benjaporn Inseemeesak Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University
  • Ratchatee Techapiesancha-Roenkij Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University
  • Ampika Bansiddhi Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University
  • Monchanok Vijarnsorn Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kasetsart University




Titanium, Adhesion, Hydroxyapatite, Solution combustion, Internal fixation


Hydroxyapatite (HA, Ca10(PO4)6(OH)2) is a biomaterial exploited in bone graft and implant coating applications. The present study aimed at developing the technique employed in coating hydroxyapatite onto internal fixation titanium plates. The coating consisted of hydroxyapatite layer and titanium dioxide layer, functioning as a buffer layer between hydroxyapatite and titanium plate substrate. The titanium substrates were i) untreated; ii) polished and immersed in 70% nitric acid; and iii) immersed in nitric acid. Coating of titanium dioxide and hydroxyapatite layers were achieved via hydrothermal technique. Porous hydroxyapatite layers with the average pore size close to 120 µm, and porosity ranging from 40 to 45% were observed. Fair adhesion among titanium substrate, titanium dioxide and hydroxyapatite layers were found in the samples prepared by polishing and acid immersion and the ones prepared by acid immersion. A peeling method (ASTM D3359 – 09E2), used in evaluation of adhesion on a 0B to 5B scale, was employed in determination of adhesion strength of the coating. The peeling results revealed that complete detachment of the buffer and hydroxyapatite layers occurred in untreated substrates. For the polished and acid immersed samples, the 2B category adhesion, which corresponds to film removal between 15 to 35%, was observed. The observation was being agreed with the image analysis which indicated that 67.7%-69% of coated area remained. Potential biocompatibility was tested by simulated body fluid (SBF) immersion. After 28 days, pH values remained unchanged. Slight weight increase and hydroxyapatite formation after immersion was observed, indicating potential bioactivity of the samples.


Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Benjaporn Inseemeesak, Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University

Ratchatee Techapiesancha-Roenkij, Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University

Department of Materials Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University

Ampika Bansiddhi, Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University

Department of Materials Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Kasetsart University

Monchanok Vijarnsorn, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kasetsart University

Department of Small Animal Clinical Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kasetsart University


O. Jongprateep, N. Wattana, N. Sato, P. T. Kien, and B. Inseemeesak, “Effects of solid loadings and silica addition on microstructure and compressive strength of hydroxyapatite specimens fabricated by freeze casting technique,” Ceramics International, vol. 44(1), pp. 156-160, 2018.

M. Nazir, O. P. Ting, T. S. Yee, S. Pushparajan, D. Swaminathan, and M. G. Kutty, “Biomimetic coating of modified titanium surfaces with hydroxyapatite using simulated body fluid,” Advances in Materials Science and Engineering, pp. 1-8, 2015.

R. S. Corpe, D. E. Steflik, R. Y. MD Whitehead, T. R. Young, and C. Jaramillo, “Correlative experimental animal and human clinical retrieval evaluation of hydroxyapatite (HA)-coated and non-coated implants in orthopaedics and dentistry,” Critical Reviews in Biomedical Engineering, vol. 28, pp. 395-398, 2000.

R. Sakkers, R. Dalmeyer, R. Brand, P. Rozing, and C. Van Blitterswijk, “Assessment of bioactivity for orthopaedics coating in a gaphealing model,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 36, pp. 265-273, 1998.

R. Family, M. Solati-Hashjin, S. N. Nik, and A. Nemati, “Surface modification for titanium implants by hydroxyapatite nanocomposite,” Caspian Journal of Internal Medicine, vol. 3, pp. 460-465, 2012.

N. R. Ha, Z. X. Yang, K. H. Hwang, and J. K. Lee, “Formation of TiO2 coating layer on the surface treated Ti alloys,” Materials Science Forum, vol. 569, pp. 177-180, 2008.

A. Arifin, A. B Sulong, N. Muhamad, J. Syarif, and M. I, Ramli, “Material processing of hydroxyapatite and titanium alloy (HA/Ti) composite as implant materials using powder metallurgy: A review,” Materials and Design, vol. 55, pp. 165-175, 2014.

A. V. Popkov, E. N. Gorbach, N. A. Kononovich, D. A. Popkov, S. I. Tverdokhlebov and E. V. Shesterikov, “Bioactivity and osteointegration of hydroxyapatite-coated stainless steel and titanium wires used for intramedullary osteosynthesis,” Strat Traum Limb Recon, vol. 12, pp. 107-113, 2017.

T. Laonapakul, A. R. Nimkerdphol, and Y. Otsuka, “Failure behavior of plasma- sprayed hap coating on commercially pure titanium substrate in simulated body fluid (SBF) under bending load,” Journal Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. vol. 15, 153-166, 2012.

Z. Zumrut, B. D. Polat, I. Akin, O. Keles, and G. Goller, “Bioactivity characterization and a full factorial design on the adhesive strength of air plasma sprayed HA-TiO2 coatings,” Journal of the Australian Ceramic Society, vol. 49, pp. 95-103, 2013.

J. Hsiung, J. Tzeng, K. Kung, and H. Chen, “A study of hermal sprayc oating on artificial knee joints,” Journal Life Science. vol. 10, pp. 236- 241, 2013.

Y. Yang, K.-H. Kim, and J. L. Ong, “A review on calcium phosphate coatings produced using a sputtering process - an alternative to plasma spraying,” Biomaterials, vol. 26, pp. 327-337, 2005.

K. Ozeki, Y. Fukui, and H. Aoki, “Hydroxyapatite coated dental implants by sputter-ing,” Biocybernetics and Biomedical Engineering, vol. 26, pp. 95-101, 2006.

X. Ji, W. Lou, Q. Wang, J. Ma, H. Xu, Q. Bai, C. Liu, and J. Liu, “Sol–gel-derived hydroxylapatite-carbon nanotube/titania coatings on titanium substrates,” International Journal of Molecular Sciences, vol. 13, pp. 5242-5253, 2012.

C. J. Tredwin, G. Georgiou, H. W. Kim, and J. C. Knowles, “Hydroxyapatite, fluorhydroxyapatite and fluorapatite produced via the sol-gel method: bonding to titanium and scanning electron microscopy,” Dental Materials Journal, vol. 29, pp. 521-529, 2013.

T. Li, J. Lee, T. Kobayashi, and H. Aoki, Hydroxyapatite coating by dipping method, and bone bonding strength,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 7, pp.355-357. 1996.

E. Mohseni, E. Z. alnezhad, and A. R. Bushroa, “Comparative in vestigation on the adhesion of hydroxyapatite coating onTi–6Al–4V implant: A review paper,” International Journal of Adhesion and Adhesives, vol. 48, pp. 238-257, 2014

B. Ben-Nissan, A. H. Choi, R. Roest, B. A. Latella, and A. Bendavid, “Adhesion of hydroxyapatite on titanium medical implants,” Woodhead Publishing Series in Biomaterials, vol. 2, pp. 21-51, 2015.

M. Textor, C. Sittig, V. Frauchiger, S. Tosatti, and D. M. Brunette, “7-Properties and Biological Significance of Natural Oxide Films on Titanium and Its Alloys,” in Handbook of Titanium in Medicine, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, pp. 171-230, 2001.

T. Kokubo and H. Takadama, “7-Simulated Body Fluid (SBF) as a Standard Tool to Test the Bioactivity of Implants,” in Handbook of Biomineralization: Biological Aspects and Structure Formation, ed. Edmund Bauerlein Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH and Co. KGaA, Weinheim, pp. 97-106, 2007.

K. Suchanek, A. Bartkowiak, A. Gdowik, M. Perzanowski, S. Kąc, B. Szaraniec, M. Suchanek, and M. Marszałek, “Crystalline hydroxyapatite coatings synthesized under hydrothermal conditions on modified titanium substrates,” Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 51, pp. 57-63, 2015

F. Namavar, R. F Sabirianov, D. Marton, A. Rubinstein, and K. L. Garvin, “Why is Titanium Biocompatible,” Poster No. 0981, ORS 2012 Annual Meeting.

P. Mandracci, F. Mussano, P. Rivolo, and S. Carossa, “Surface Treatments and Functional Coatings for Biocompatibility Improvement and Bacterial Adhesion Reduction in Dental Implantology, Coatings, vol. 6(7), pp. 1-22, 2016.

V. Karageorgiou and D. Kaplan, “Porosity of 3D biomaterial scaffolds and osteogenesis,” Biomaterials, vol. 26, pp. 5474-5491, 2005.

M. Mour, D. Das, T. Winkler, E. Hoenig, G. Mielke and M. M. Morlock, “Advances in porous biomaterials for dental and orthopaedic applications,” Materials, vol. 3 pp. 2947-2974, 2010.

A. Tsuchiya, S. Sotome1, Y. A. Soul, M. Kikuchi, Y. Koyama, T. Ogawa, J. Tanaka, and K. Shinomiya, “Effects of pore size and implant volume of porous hydroxyapatite/collagen (HAp/Col) on bone formation in a rabbit bone defect model,” Journal of Medical and Dental Sciences, vol. 55, pp. 91-99, 2008.

D. Davies and J. A. Whittaker, “Methods of testing the adhesion of metal coatings to metals,” Metallurgical Reviews, vol. 12, pp. 15-26, 1967.

B. N. Chapman, “Thin-film adhesion,” Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology, vol. 11, pp.106-113, 1974.

E. Conforto, B. O. Aronsson, A. Salito, C. Crestou, and D. Caillard, “Rough surfaces of titanium and titanium alloys for implants and prostheses,” Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 24(5), pp. 611-618, 2004.

O. Zinger, K. Anselme, and A. Denzer, “Timedependent morphology and adhesion of osteoblastic cells on titanium model surfaces featuring scale-resolved topography,” Biomaterials, vol. 25(14), pp. 2695-2711, 2004.

T. Monetta and F. Bellucci, “The effect of sand-blasting and hydrofluoric acid etching on Ti CP 2 and Ti CP 4 surface topography,” Open Journal of Regenerative Medicine, vol. 1(3), pp. 41-50, 2012.

M. David Dohan Ehrenfest, P. G. Coelho, B. Kang, Y.-T. Sul, and T. Albrektsson, “Classification of osseointegrated implant surfaces: materials, chemistry and topography,” Trends in Biotechnology, Vol. 28(4), pp. 198-206, 2010.

M. D. Korotin, S. Bartkowski, E. Z. Kurmaev, M. Meumann, E. B. Yakushina, R. Z. Valiev, and S. O. Cholakh, “Surface Characterization of Titanium Implants Treated in Hydrofluoric Acid,” Journal of Biomaterials and Nanobiotechnology, vol. 3, pp. 87-91, 2012.

P. Vanzillotta, G. A. Soares, I. N. Bastos, R. A. Simao, and N. K. Kuromoto, “Potentialities of some surface characterization techniques for the development of titanium biomedical alloys,” Materials Research, vol. 7(3), pp. 437-444, 2004.

S. Ferraris, S. Spriano, and G. Pan, “Surface modification of Ti-6Al-4V alloy for biomineralization and specific biological response: part I, inorganic modification,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 22(3), pp. 533-545, 2011.

C. T. Kwok, P. K. Wong, F. T. Cheng, and H. C. Man, “Characterization and corrosion behavior of hydroxyapatite coatings on Ti6Al4V fabricated by electrophoretic deposition,” Applied Surface Science, vol. 255(13-14), pp. 6736-6744, 2009.

X. F. Xiao, R. F. Liu, and Y. Z. Zheng. “Characterization of hydroxyapatite/titania composite coatings codeposited by a hydrothermal-electrochemical method on titanium,” Surface and Coatings Technology, vol. 200, pp. 4406-4413, 2006.

M. B. Rosa, T. Albrektsson, C. E. Francischone, H. O. S. Filho, and A. Wennerberg, “The influence of surface treatment on the implant roughness pattern,” Journal of Applied Oral Science, vol. 20(5), pp. 550-555, 2012.

U. W. Jung, J. W. Hwang, D. Y. Choi, K. S. Hu, M. K. Kwon, S. H. Choi, and H. J. Kim, “Surface characteristics of a novel hydroxyapatitecoated dental implant,” Journal of Periodontal & Implant Science, vol. 42(2), pp. 59-63, 2012.

H. Ishizawa and M. Ogino, “Characterization of thin hydroxyapatite layers formed on anodic titanium oxide films containing Ca and P by hydrothermal treatment,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 29, pp. 1071-1079, 1995.

D. L. Alontseva, M. B. Abilev, A. M. Zhilkashinova, S. G.Voinarovych, O. N. Kyslytsia, E. Ghassemieh, A. Russakova, and L. Łatka, “Optimization of Hydroxyapatite Synthesis and Microplasma Spraying of Porous Coatings Onto Titanium Implants,” Vol. Advances in Materials Science, vol. 18(57), pp 79-94, 2018.

B. Plesngerova, G. SucikGabriel Sucik, M. Maryska, and D. Horkavcova, “Hydroxyapatite coatings deposited from alcohol suspensions by electrophoretic deposition on titanium substrate,” Ceramics-Silikaty, vol. 51(1), pp 15-23, 2007.

L. Yehuang, K. Weixu, and J. Lu, “A study of the process and kinetics of electrochemical deposition and the hydrothermal synthesis of hydroxyapatite coatings,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine, vol. 11, pp. 667-673, 2000.

H. Wang, Z. Meifang, Y. Li, Q. Zhang, and H. Wang, Mechanical properties of dental resin composites by co-filling diatomite and nanosized silica particles, Materials Science and Engineering C, vol. 31, pp. 600-605, 2011.

D. M. Liu, “Influence of porosity and pore size on the compressive strength of porous hydroxyapatite ceramic,” Ceramics International, vol. 23, pp. 135-139, 1997.




How to Cite

O. Jongprateep, B. Inseemeesak, R. Techapiesancha-Roenkij, A. Bansiddhi, and M. Vijarnsorn, “Effects of surface modification processes on the adhesion of hydroxyapatite layers coated onto titanium substrates”, J Met Mater Miner, vol. 29, no. 4, Dec. 2019.



Original Research Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)