Hot ductility and hot-shortness of steel and measurement techniques: A review
Usage of steel scrap has become important in steel making from the view points of resource conservation and preventing environmental problems. High levels of steel scraps are used in the production of steel, especially, via electric arc furnaces (EAF). However, Copper, which is mainly contained in the scrap of cars and home electronic appliance, is problematic in mechanical workings at elevated temperatures and limits the usage of scrap iron. It is enriched at steel/scale interface by preferential oxidation of Fe, which leads to liquid embrittlement or surface cracking during hot working. This type of defect is well known as surface hot shortness. Cu has been also reported to give surface cracking problem including transverse cracking in continuously cast products and has been found to be detrimental to surface quality. While nickel and silicon have been added to prevent hot shortness and cracking problem, tin, antimony and arsenic are detrimental. Silicon modifies scale of copper-bearing steels and promotes internal oxidation by the formation of 2FeO.SiO2 (fayalite). The evaluation techniques of hot shortness and cracking problem are also equally important and are mainly evaluated by hot tensile and hot bend test after oxidation. In addition to this, hot tensile test has been also used for evaluating hot ductility behaviour and surface cracks of continuously cast products.
Melford, D.A. (1980). “The Influence of Residual and Trace Elements on Hot Shortness and High Temperature Embrittlement”, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. 295(A) : 89-103
Marschman, S.C. (2015). On a Thermodynamic Approach to Material Selection for Service in Aggressive Multi-Component Gaseous and/or Vapor Environments, Technical Report • October DOI:10.13140/ RG.2.1.1390.6648.
Stephenson, E.T. (1983). “Effect of Recycling on Residuals, Processing, and Properties of Carbon and Low-Alloy Steels”, Metall. Trans. A, 14A : 343-353
Hartley, A.J., Eastburn, P. and Leece, N. (1980) “Steelworks Control of Residuals”. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 295 : 45-55 4. Nicholson, A. and Murray, J.D. (1965). “Surface Hot Shortness in Low-carbon Steel”, Journal of The Iron and Steel Institute. 203(10) : 1007-1018.
Copeland, M.I., and Kelley, J.E. (1972). “Reducing Surface Hot Shortness of Copper-bearing Steels”. Bureau of Mines Report of Investigations. 7682 : 1-19
Melford, D.A. (1962). “Surface Hot Shortness in Mild Steel”, Journal of The Iron and Steel Institute. 200(4) : 290-299.
Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams, Second Edition, Volume 2, Edited by T.B. Massalski, H. Okamoto, P.R. Subramanian, L. Kacprzak, ASM International, (1990).
Zou, Y., and Langer, E.W. (1989). “A Study of the Formation and Penetration of the Molten Copper-rich Phase in Iron with the Addition of Nickel and Tin”, Materials
Born, K. (1953). “Surface Defects in the Hot Working of Steel from Residual Copper and Tin”, Stahl und Eisen, 73(20) : 1268-1277.
Habraken, L. and Lecomte-Beckers, J. (1982). “Hot Shortness and Scaling of Coppercontaining Steels”, Copper in Iron and Steel, Edited by L. McDonald Schetky, John Waley & Sons, New York, 45-81.
Suzuki, H. (1997). “Strain Rate Dependence of Cu Embrittlement in Steels”. ISIJ International. 37(3) : 250-254.
Kohsaka, Y. and Ouchi, C. “Hot Shortness of Copper Bearing High Strength Low Alloy Steels”, ATB Metallurgie. 23 , 9.1- 9.29 (1983).
Wolf, M. Schwabe, H. (1986). “On Tramp Element Control in Electric Steelmaking”, Proc. 2nd European Electric Steel Congress, Florence, Italy, 29 Sept.-1 Oct., 4.8/1– 4.8/34
Mayland, K., Welburn, R.W. and Nicholson, A. (1976). “Influence of Microstructural and Compositional Variables on Hot Working of Steel”. Metals Technology. 3(8) : 350-357.
Nicholson, A. and Murray, J.D. (1965). “Surface Hot Shortness in Low-carbon Steel”, Journal of The Iron and Steel Institute. 203(10) : 1007-1018
O’Neill, D.S. (2002). An Investigation of Surface Hot Shortness in Low Carbon Steel, PhD thesis, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Faculty of Science,The University of New South Wales, Australia, P.113.
Akamatsu, S. Senuma, T. Takada, Y. Hasebe, M.(1999).“Effect of nickel and tin additions on formation of liquid phase in copper bearing steels during high temperature oxidation”, Materials Science and Technology, 15, November, 1301- 1307
Imai, N. Komatsubara, N. Kunishige, K. (1997). “Effect of Cu and Ni on Hot Workability of Hot-rolled Mild Steel”, ISIJ International, 37 , 224-231
Fisher, G.L. (1969). “The Effect of Nickel on the High-TemperatureOxidation Characteristics of Copper-bearing Steels”, Journal of The Iron and Steel Institute, 207 , 1010-1016
Fukagawa, T. Fujikawa, H. (1999). “Effect of Small Amounts of Ni on Liquid-Cu Embrittlement in Hot- Rolled Mild Steel After High-Temperature Oxidation”, Oxidation of Metals, 52, October, 177- 194
Koji Shibata, Soek-Jong Seo, Masashi Kaga, Hiroshi Uchino, Akio Sasanuma, kentaro Asakura and Chihiro Nagasaki, (2002), Suppression of Surface Hot Shortness Caused by Cu in Recycled Steels, Materials Transactions, 43p292- 300.
Nagumo, M. Hida, Y. (1983). “Hot Shortness of Copper-Containing Steel in the Controlled Rolling Process”, ATB Metallurgie, 23 (3), 10.1-10.19
Lanteri, V. Huin, D. Drillet, P. Bouleau, D. Henry, P. Gaye, H. (1996). “Internal Oxidation of Fe-Si Alloys in the Presence of External Scale”, Microscopy of Oxidation 3, Edited by S.B. Newcomb and J.A. Little, Proc. Third International Conference on the Microscopy of Oxidation, 16-18 September, 535-550
Kajitani, T. Wakoh, M. Tokumitsu, N. Ogibayashi, S. Mizoguchi, S. (1995). “Influence of Heating Temperature and Strain on Surface Crack in Carbon Steel Induced by Residual Copper”, Tetsu to Hogane (Japanese), 81 , 29-34
Thomas, B. G. Brimacombe, J.K. and Samarasekera, I. V.( 1986). The formation of panel cracks in steel ingots: A state of the art review, ISS Transactions, Vol. 7, 7- 20.
Harada, S. Tanaka, S. Misumi, H. Mizoguchi, S. Horiguchi, H. (1990). “A formation Mechanism of transverse Cracks on CC Slab Surface”, ISIJ Int., 30, 310-316..
Hater M. et. al., (1973), “Results From a Curved Mould Continuous Casting Machine Making Pipe and Plate Steel”, “Open Hearth Proceedings”, AIME, 202- 217.
Burden, M. H. Funnell, G. D. Whitaker, A. G. and Young, J. M. (1979), Solidification and Castings of Metals, the Metals Society, London 279-286.
Woollen,G. (1990). Personalcommunication, British Steel, Scunthorpe Works.
Lankford, W. T. (1972) “Considerations of Strength and Ductility in the ContinuousCasting Process”, Metall. Trans.,3, 1331-1357.
Crowther, D. N. (2001), “The effects of microalloying ele ments on cracking during continuous casting,” in Pro ceedings of Conference on the Use of Vanadium in Steel, Beijing pp. 99–131.
McPherson N. A. (1980), and R.E. Mercer: “Continuous Casting of Slabs at BSC Ravenscraig Works”, Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 167-179.
Lankford, W. T. (1972,) “Considerations of Strength and Ductility in the ContinuousCasting Process”, Metall. Trans., 3, 1331- 1357.
Wilber G. A. et. al., (1975,) “The effects of Thermal History and Composition on the Hot Ductility of Low Carbon Steels”, Metall., Trans., 6A, 1727-1735.
Yasumoto Y. et. al., (1985), “Effects of Sulphur on the Hot Ductility of Low Carbon Steel Austenite”, Mat. Sci. and Technol.,1, 111-116.
Maehara Y.et.al., (1990),“Surface Cracking Mechanism of Continuously Cast Low Carbon Low Alloy Steel Slabs” Mat. Sci. and Technol., 6, 793-806.
Bannenberg N.et. al., “Procedures for Successful Continuos Casting of Steel Microalloyed with Nb, V Ti and N”, Microalloying 95, 83-94.
HaradaS.et.al.,(1990),“Aformation Mechanism of transverse Cracks on CC Slab Surface”, ISIJ Int., 30, 310-316.
Hannerz: N. E. (1985), “Critical Hot Plasticity and Transverse Cracking in Continuous Slab Casting with Particular reference to Composition” Trans ISIJ, 25, 149158.
Suzuki,H.G. Nishimura, S.and Yamaguchi, S. (1982), “Characteristics of Hot Ductility in Steels Subjected to the Melting and Solidification,” ISIJ Trans., (22),pp. 48-56.
Robbins, J. L. Shepard O. C. and Sherby, O. D. (1999), “Role of Crystal Structure on the Ductility of Pure Iron at Elevated Temperature,”JISI, October 1961, pp. 175-180.
Mintz B. and Arrowsmith, J. M. (1979), “Hotductility behaviour of C-Mn-Nb-Al Steels and its relationship to crack Propagation During the straightening of Continuously Cast Strand”, Met. Technol., 6, 24- 32.
Suzuki H. G. et. al. (1984),”Embrittlement of Steels Occurring in the Temperature Range from 1000 to 600°C”, Trans ISIJ, 24, 169-177.
Ouchi, C. and Matsumoto, K. (1982). “Hot Ductility in Nb-bearing High Strength Low-alloy Steels”, Trans. ISIJ 22 : 181- 189.
Mintz, B. Abushosa R. and Cowley A. (1998),: “Preliminary analysis of hot ductility curve in simple C-Mn steels”, Mat. Sci., and Technol., Volume 14, pp. 222-226.
Suzuki,HC.NishimuraS.andNakamura,Y. (1 9 8 ),“Characteristics of the Embrittlement in Steels Near the Melting Temperature,”100thISIJ Meeting, October S805.
Crowther D. N. and Mintz B. (1986),: “Influence of Grain Size and Precipitation on Hot Ductility of Microalloyed Steels”, Mat. Sci. and Technol., 2, 1099-1105.
Liu G. X. and Dahl W. (1989),: “The Influence of Temperature and Strain Rate on the Stress-Strain Behaviour of “in-situ solidified” Steel During tensile Test”, Steel Research, 60, 221-229.
Deprez, P. Bricout, J. P. and Oudin J. (1992),: “A New Tensile Test on in situ Solidified Notched Specimens: Hot Ductility Analysis of Continuous Casting Steels” , J. Mat. Proc. Technol., 32, 325- 334.
Revaux T. et. al., (1994), “In Situ Solidified Hot Tensile Test and Hot Ductility of Some Plain Cabon Steels and Microalloyed Steels”, ISIJ International, 34, 528-535.
Mintz, B., Stewart, J. M. and Crowther, D. N. (1987). “The Influence of Cyclic Temperature Oscillations on Precipitation and Hot Ductility of a CMn-Nb-Al Steel”, Trans. ISIJ, , 27 : 959-964.
Cardoso, G.I.S.L. Mintz B. and Yue, S. (1995),: “Hot Ductility of Aluminium and Titanium Containing Steels With and Without Cyclic Temperature Oscillations”, Iron making and Steelmaking, 5, 365- 377.
Influence of thermal history on hot ductility of steel and its relationship to the problem of cracking in continuous casting K. M. Banks, A. Tuling and B. Mintz, Materials Science and Technology (2012) VOL 28, 536-542.
Mintz, B. Abushosa R.and Crowther, D. N. “Influence of Small Additions of Copper and Nickel on Hot Ductility of Steels”, Mat. Sci. and Technol., (1995), 11, 474- 481.
Suzuki, H. G. Nishimura S.and S. Yamaguchi: “Physical Simulation of The Continuous Casting of Steels”, Proc. Conf. on Physical Simulation Techniques for Welding, Hot forming and Continuous Casting, 1988, Canmet, Ottowa.
Mintz B. and Yue, S. (1992),: “The Hot Tensile test For Assessing the Likelihood of Transverse Cracking During Continuous Casting of Steel”, 34th Mechanical Working and Steel Processing Conference, 391-398.
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2017 Journal of Metals, Materials and Minerals
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish in this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this journal.